Happy Goat Horror

When I first heard the buzz about Coming Home in the Dark, I wasn’t sure what to expect. The premise—family on a road trip, attacked by a pair of criminals with deeply personal motivations—sounded like a solid thriller, but something about it also felt like a twist on a familiar formula. Little did I know, what I was in for was a dark, merciless descent into human nature and past trauma, a gut-punch of a film that sticks with you long after the credits roll.

“Sometimes you have to look into the past to survive the present.”

The Premise

The film opens with a simple road trip that quickly goes awry. A family—mom, dad, and their teenage son—are accosted by two criminals, Mandrake and Tubs. As they take the family hostage and begin driving them to an isolated location, they reveal their knowledge of the family’s past, particularly the father’s dark history. What follows is a harrowing exploration of trauma, revenge, and violence, with each new revelation escalating the tension until it becomes unbearable.

The narrative doesn’t waste time with subtlety. It moves fast, immediately putting the viewer on edge with its chilling first encounter. It quickly becomes clear that this is not just a random attack—there’s personal history at play, and the deeper we get, the more unsettling it becomes. It’s a thriller that strips down any sense of safety, reminding us that the past doesn’t always stay buried.

“Sometimes it’s not just the criminals you have to fear.”

The Execution

Coming Home in the Dark leans heavily on its characters, particularly the father, played by Erik Thomson. His performance is raw and layered, bringing depth to a man who’s trying to protect his family from a past he cannot escape. His vulnerability—particularly when it’s revealed that his own past may have contributed to the attack—is haunting, and Thomson plays it with heartbreaking intensity.

The criminals, Mandrake (played by Daniel Gillies) and Tubs (played by Matthias Luafutu), add a disturbing unpredictability to the film. Mandrake, especially, is a force of nature, full of rage and cynicism, while Tubs is more calculated, his calm demeanor only making him more chilling. Together, they create an unnerving duo, each interaction laden with tension and danger.

The cinematography works well to amplify the isolation of the setting—the rugged New Zealand wilderness, with its vast, empty spaces, contrasts sharply with the close, claustrophobic feeling inside the car. The use of silence is also incredibly effective, allowing the audience to sit in the discomfort of the situation and truly feel the weight of each decision the characters make.

“The past never stays buried. It waits.”

The Horror Elements

Now, let’s talk about the horror in this film. It’s not about ghosts or monsters lurking in the shadows; the real terror comes from the characters’ own demons and the violence they are forced to face. The film has an unsettling realism to it, making it feel as though it could happen to anyone. The brutality is stark, and the violence doesn’t feel gratuitous—it feels purposeful, a necessary evil in telling the story of a family facing the consequences of their past actions.

What makes the horror even more effective is the emotional impact it has on the characters. The violence they endure doesn’t just leave physical scars; it drags them back to the past, forcing them to confront mistakes, regrets, and guilt that they would rather leave behind. This emotional depth makes the horrors all the more real.

“Sometimes redemption comes at a price.”

Final Thoughts

So, is Coming Home in the Dark perfect? Not quite. The pacing can feel a bit uneven at times, especially in the middle act, where the film shifts between moments of tense action and slower, more reflective sequences. Some viewers may also find it difficult to fully connect with the characters, especially the teenage son, whose role feels a bit underdeveloped in comparison to the adults.

But these are minor quibbles in what is otherwise a powerful, tense, and thought-provoking film. If you’re looking for a film that doesn’t hold back in its depiction of the darkness lurking within human nature, Coming Home in the Dark is a solid choice. Just be prepared for an emotional rollercoaster, and maybe a bit of discomfort as you watch the past and present collide in the most brutal of ways.

---

Strengths • Exceptional performances from the leads, particularly Erik Thomson as the father.
• Atmosphere-rich in tension and dread, with cinematography that makes the wilderness feel as menacing as the criminals themselves.
• An unflinching exploration of trauma, guilt, and revenge.

Weaknesses • The plot can occasionally feel a bit predictable, reducing some of the suspense.
• While the adults are well fleshed out, the teenage son feels underdeveloped in comparison.

Score: 7.5 – It’s raw, brutal, and emotionally charged, with a heavy price paid for any semblance of redemption. Definitely worth the watch if you’re in the mood for a film that doesn’t shy away from the darkness.