All Hallows’ Eve – edited by Ellen Datlow || Book Review

Hugo Award winning editor and horror legend Ellen Datlow presents this chilling horror anthology of 19 original short stories from a world-class line-up of the masters of horror, delving into the histories and traditions of the spookiest season of the year.

Featuring stories by Josh Malerman, Stephen Graham Jones, Garth Nix and many more.

Halloween, Samhain, Día de los Muertos—festivals across the world where we can commune with those we have lost, when spirits can cross over, and when the boundary between the living and the dead is far, far too thin.

A young boy encounters a woman with an ancient and terrifying link to the holiday, a group of college students attend a Halloween party to die for, and a troubled girl exploits a local urban legend to try and turn her life around.

From America to New Zealand via the rural Romanian wilderness, this anthology explores our worldwide obsession with the spookiest season of the year, when the veil is lifted and the spirits come alive. Featuring 19 original stories from bestselling and award-winning masters of the genre, and from Hugo, World Fantasy, Locus, Bram Stoker and Shirley Jackson award-winning editor and horror legend Ellen Datlow, this anthology invites you to carve a pumpkin, light the lanterns and welcome in trick or treaters from across the world.

Dark bleatings, my lovely tribe. I meant to get this review up last month, and normally would have, but some personal circumstances (good ones) are causing delays. Regardless, this anthology kept me entertained through spooky season so we’re here to talk about it.

As the title suggests, this anthology is made up of original stories exploring not just Halloween, but the spooky seasons of several different cultures. I was excited to dive in because of that, not to mention the brilliant line-up of authors:

Josh Malerman
Lee Murray
Rich Larson
Clay McLeod Chapman
Livia Llewellyn
Michael Marshall Smith
Stephen Graham Jones
Linda D. Addison
Christopher Golden
Alma Katsu
Brian Evenson
Siobhan Carroll
Chịkọdịlị Emelụmadụ
Theresa DeLucci
Garth Nix
Jeffrey Ford
Richard Kadrey
Nathan Ballingrud
John Langan

We begin with Josh Malerman’s ‘That Hannie Agnes’, a short creepy story of a teacher recounting a memory of Halloween that made him dislike the holiday. It’s a creepy, punchy read and a great opener. ‘On the Path, Bleeding’ by Lee Murray follows – a sinister tale of a man performing a gang initiation but somehow bites off more than he can chew, even for these kinds of stakes! (I realise my wording makes it sound like a vampire story but it isn’t).

Rich Larson’s ‘Good Kids’ takes the book on a demonic turn, swiftly followed by Clay McLeod Chapman’s ‘Treats’, which changes the tone completely with a past tragedy appearing in our protagonist’s present. This is one of my favourites. ‘The Levels’ by Livia Llewellyn sent me into existential dread, and then Michael Marshall Smith distracted me from that anxiety with the most loathsome character in ‘Forever Again’, which has an air of ‘just desserts’ about it.

Stephen Graham Jones takes the baton next with ‘The Devil’s New Year’, and delivers a unique protagonist with, let’s say, an interesting tattoo and the lengths she’s willing to go to in removing it. We’re then treated to a change in format entirely with a fabulous poem called ‘Merciless Feast’ by Linda D. Addison, which tells of a sacrifice going wrong…even for a sacrifice. Christopher Golden’s ‘Or So the Story Goes’ swoops in next with what I would call the most festive of the stories, giving us delightfully nasty monsters and someone caught in the crossfire.

Alma Katsu’s ‘The Kuker’ freaks us out next. It’s the story of a woman in grief, cleaning out her husband’s things, starting with a creepy costume that she always hated but now suddenly has the urge to try on…

Brian Evenson’s ‘Ankou’s Night’ is also delightfully creepy in its telling of a boy’s horrible grandfather dying but not wanting to stay gone. Siobhan Carroll, Chikodili Emelumadu, Theresa DeLucci, Garth Nix, and Jeffrey Ford delight, shock, mystify, and depending on your personal brand of fear, horrify us next with their subsequent tales, each exploring a different element of a different kind of spooky season, offering plenty of variety.

Richard Kadrey’s ‘Dare Me’ really caught my attention. Our protagonist, a kid called Tommy, in a bid to forge a friendship with a group, is excited to execute a Halloween prank but oh, how hideous things go. Nathan Ballingrud also delighted me with ghouls in ‘On the Night of the Welcome Stranger’. Do you have any idea how hard it is to find great ghouls stories, of ghouls proper? I was so pleased when I realised what I was reading here. The anthology rounds off with John Langan’s ‘The Auld Woman with the Broom’ which….I mean, if you’ve read any Langan then you’ll know the tone he scars us for life with.

For my personal tastes, the only thing I wish I’d got a bit more of is being terrorised. It’s a highly subjective thing to be scared, and the level of fright experienced will obviously differ drastically from reader to reader, though, so take that very mild complaint with the pinch of salt it’s intended with. What I really liked as I made my way through this charcuterie of chaos, besides the individual stories on their own merits, was the variety offered in how to tell seasonally spooky tales. I also think the stories were placed in the perfect running order, allowing for lots of surprise and tone changing.

If you’re looking for something to enjoy during these dark nights and like a good solid atmosphere, the authors did a great job here.

If you’d like to check out the book or the editor, I’ve popped some links below for you:

ALL HALLOW’S EVE

ELLEN DATLOW

Bleeeeat!

Leave a Reply